WITH
Missy's street cred, Alicia's devotion to old- school R&B and Beyoncé's
urban pop, the Ladies First tour at Nassau Coliseum Thursday was a three-way
jam on hip-hop street.
Which side you take in the argument of who was best during this 41/2-hour extravaganza
depends on what you look for in a concert: Elliott's set was the most personable,
Keys' the most musical and Beyoncé's all about razzle-dazzle production.
Beyoncé owned the headlining slot and took full advantage of it, with
plenty of over-the-top staging, costume changes and a female dance troupe with
a very impressive repertoire of hip swivels and wiggles.
You'd have to be in denial not to be impressed with her Cleopatra entrance on
a flouncy, man-powered litter carried shoulder-high. Like a queen, she scattered
white rose petals in her wake as her rig trudged through the crowd, toward the
stage, for her belly-dancing hit, "Baby Boy."
Make no mistake: Beyoncé is a powerful vocalist and she actually sings
in concert.
Her costume changes may have seemed excessive, but these quick offstage swaps
lent every song a personality and gave her time to catch her breath.
Yet even with all the eye-popping production numbers, it was on the simply played
encore tune, "Crazy in Love," where she hit her high.
At other gigs, she's had to depend on a video of her boyfriend Jay-Z, but at
Nassau, she coaxed him out of his self-imposed retirement to do his part live.
Despite his brief stage time, Jay-Z looked and sounded terrific and was the
concert's cherry on top.
Keys, who preceded Beyoncé, offered a very choreographed set, splitting
her time between piano and kick-it-up dance moves. In the past, she's seemed
uncomfortable and clumsy when shaking it up, but this performance found her
more polished and graceful.
But Keys hit all of her personal bests when she was at her piano singing; songs
such as "Fallin' " and her cascading ballad "You Don't Know My
Name" rightly thrilled the house.
As for Missy, the crowd loved her just for being Missy. She has an electric
presence that had the fans on their feet moving to each number without any concern
for the incredibly bad sound that made the raps indiscernible.
If anyone understood her versions of "Get Ur Freak On" and "Supa
Dupa Fly," it was more from memory than clarity.
Missy's abbreviated, 40-minute set was disturbing; she was allotted five minutes
less than it took to get the stage ready for Keys.
While this was a good show with some great moments, it could have been better
with a few simple fixes.
Had the trio of stars agreed on a shared stage, all the downtime could have
been eliminated and ongoing momentum could have been built, instead of each
act having to build its own.
The other trick this concert missed was that these three great performers never
were on stage together. What a mistake.
The three shoulda, coulda worked out a tune that wasn't associated with any
of them, like an upbeat Supremes classic. With Keys on piano and trading vocals
with Beyoncé, and Elliott interpolating a rap line, it could have been
the showstopper that defined this concert.
By
DAN AQUILANTE,
NYP